Mary Zimmerman (center), 2013-14 Alternate Dairy Princess, is surrounded by her sisters wearing their former Dairy Princess crowns.  

1976 - Mary Ruth Delbaugh

1977 - Cathy Simonton Civello

1978 - Lou Ann Hoffman Davidson

1979 - Jackie Stoner Wilt

1980 - Denise Love Knepp

1981 - Sally Hoover Lizardi

1982 - Ruth Ryan Showalter

1984 - Angie Colyer

1986 - Karen Shertzer Diffenderfer

1987 - Marjorie Shearer Swartz

1988 - Shelly Harshbarger

1989 - Melissa Imes Rardin

1991 - Melissa Adamire Delancey

1992 - Anita Faulkner

1993 - Rebecca Woodward Wilson

1994 - Melissa Hosler McKee

1997 - Judy Geissinger Mummau

1998 - Jessica Bailor Imes

2000 - Bobbi Jo Dressler Graybill

2001 - Heather Gray Imes

2002 - Rebecca Zimmerman Mosebey

2003 - Elizabeth Zimmerman Brubaker

2004 - Rachel Shearer

2005 - Stephanie Donough/Ashley Harshbarger

2007 - Kallye Faulkner

2009 - Ellen Shearer

2011 - Heidi Graybill

2012 - Leanna Hornberger

2013 - Brooke Kitting

2014 - Cheyenne Maben

2015 - Hannah Kauffman Pennepacker

2016 - Jessica Roush

2017 - Katie Fry

2018 - Marina Holderman 

​2019 - Faith Berrier

2020 - Jordan Taylor (Dairy Ambassador)